From farm-fresh milk and cream to freshly baked bread — every product on our shelves is chosen the way you'd choose it for your own table.
We stock only what we'd serve our own families — real dairy, honest breads, and pantry staples that taste like they belong in a kitchen, not a warehouse.
Whole milk, heavy cream, cultured butter, and seasonal cheeses — all sourced from local farms that share our standards.
Sourdough loaves, buttery rolls, and seasonal pastries baked in small batches so every bite carries that warm, just-out-of-the-oven taste.
Thoughtfully selected staples — from organic eggs and honey to jarred preserves and cooking essentials your household actually uses.
What the season brings, we bring to you — from summer berries and corn to holiday hams and winter root vegetables, always at peak freshness.
We partner with nearby farms and makers so every purchase supports a neighbor's livelihood and keeps dollars circulating right here in Noble County.
Planning a gathering? Call ahead and we'll set aside your favorites — whether it's a week's worth of milk, a holiday ham, or a dozen loaves for the church supper.
Forest Grove Dairy started with a simple conviction: your community deserves a place where the food on the shelf tastes like it was made with care — not shipped from somewhere you can't pronounce.
We built our selection the way you'd build your own pantry. Every carton of milk, every loaf of bread, every jar of preserves is something we'd be proud to put in front of our own family. That standard hasn't changed, no matter how many years have passed.
When you shop with us, you're not just picking up groceries. You're supporting a business that reinvests in this town, knows your name, and remembers how you take your coffee.
We're not a chain. We're your neighbors. Here's what being part of Middlebury means to us.
This is our home too. We make decisions the way a family would — with the long term in mind and the community's wellbeing at the center.
We turn down products that don't meet our standards, even when it would be easier to stock them. Your trust is worth more than a quick sale.
We sponsor local events, support school functions, and keep our doors open because this town has been good to us. That's not something we take lightly.
We're right here in Middlebury, easy to find and always happy to help you find what you need.
Have a question about our products or need to place a special order? Give us a ring.
(574) 825-8847Whether you need a week's worth of groceries or just want to grab a fresh loaf of bread, Forest Grove Dairy is here for you.
